Episode 06
Can the State Take Mom’s House? Medicaid Estate Recovery
A week before a house sale closed, the state filed an estate recovery claim. How is that legal? Here it is in six parts, straight from federal law and the federal Medicaid agency’s manual, with no state’s rules named.
Key points
- Federal law starts from a ban: no recovery of Medicaid that was correctly paid may be made, except that the state shall seek it for the people the law lists. [F1]
- For a person who was 55 or older when they received the Medicaid help, the state shall seek recovery from their estate for nursing facility services, home and community-based services, and related hospital and prescription drug services. A state can also choose to recover for other items or services under its Medicaid plan. [F2, F3]
- Recovery may be made only after the death of the person’s surviving spouse, if there is one, and only at a time when there’s no surviving child who is under 21, or who is blind or disabled. That’s a delay, not a cancellation: the claim waits. [F6]
- The estate must include everything in the person’s estate as defined by the state’s probate law. A state may choose to reach further, to other property the person had an interest in at death. [F13, F14]
- Each state Medicaid agency shall set up procedures to waive recovery when it would work an undue hardship, and the federal Medicaid agency’s manual says the notice should explain how to apply for a hardship waiver. [F8, F12]
Episode notes
The question that started it
The episode started with a real question on a Reddit estate planning forum, paraphrased here. One week before the sale of her house closed, the state filed an estate recovery claim. She had died, and the house was the only thing she owned. Their inheritance was gone. That’s how one person told it. Their question: how is this legal? We won’t answer their case for them.
Two different stages
Qualifying for Medicaid is one stage, and this page doesn’t cover it. Estate recovery is a different stage: it’s about the estate of a person who has died. [F13] And federal law starts from a ban. [F1] No recovery of Medicaid that was correctly paid may be made, except that the state shall seek it for the people the law lists. [F1] So recovery is the exception, not the rule. [F1] That’s Section 1917 of the Social Security Act. [F1]
Who and what it covers
For a person who was 55 or older when they received the Medicaid help, the state shall seek recovery from their estate, but only for certain services: nursing facility services, home and community-based services, and related hospital and prescription drug services. [F2] The age that counts is the age when the help was received, not the age at death. [F2] A state can also choose to recover for other items or services under its Medicaid plan. [F3]
When it has to wait
Federal law · a delay, not a cancellation
Federal law says recovery may be made only after the death of the person’s surviving spouse, if there is one. [F6] And only at a time when there’s no surviving child who is under 21, or who is blind or disabled. [F6] That’s a delay, not a cancellation: the claim waits. [F6] The law’s definitions of blind or disabled depend on the state’s program, so we’re keeping that part simple. [F6]
A home lien and relatives who live there
One more waiting rule involves a sibling or a son or daughter lawfully living in the home, and it applies only in a narrow case. [F7] Before death, federal law allows a lien on a person’s home only in limited situations. [F5] One example: a patient in a nursing home or other medical institution who must spend nearly all of their income on their care, and whom the state decides, after notice and a chance for a hearing, can’t reasonably be expected to return home. [F5] For a person under that kind of lien, the state shall seek recovery from the estate, or when the property under the lien is sold. [F4]
If the state has that kind of lien on the home, recovery also has to wait while a sibling or a son or daughter lawfully lives there: [F7]
- The sibling must have lived there for at least a year immediately before the person was admitted.
- The son or daughter must have lived there for at least two years immediately before admission and shown the state they provided care that let the parent stay at home.
- Either one must have lived there continuously since the admission.
What counts as the estate
Federal law says it must include everything in the person’s estate as defined by the state’s probate law: all real and personal property and other assets in it. [F13] That’s the minimum. [F13] What’s in a probate estate is a matter of state law, which earlier episodes on probate walked through. [F13]
A state may choose to reach further. [F14] Federal law lets a state include other property the person had an interest in at death, including assets passed to a survivor or heir through joint tenancy, tenancy in common, survivorship, a life estate, a living trust, or another arrangement. [F14] The federal Medicaid agency’s manual tells each state to spell out in its State plan which definition it uses: the probate one at a minimum, and the broader one if it chooses. [F15] So whether property that passes outside probate can be reached depends on the state’s definition. [F14] That’s why we won’t say a living trust or joint title avoids recovery, or that it doesn’t. [F14]
The second question: moving the deed
A second Reddit post asked about the family home, too. A mother and her adult child had both been on the home’s deed, and the mother used a quitclaim deed to take her own name off. Their question: can recovery still reach the home after she passes? It depends on how the state defines the estate, and on transfer rules this page doesn’t cover. [F14] That’s a question for the state’s Medicaid agency or a lawyer in that state.
Hardship waivers
Federal law says each state Medicaid agency shall set up procedures to waive recovery when it would work an undue hardship, under criteria set by the federal Secretary, with one exception for certain long-term care insurance cases. [F8] The federal Medicaid agency’s manual says that where recovery would work an undue hardship, it’s waived, and that states have flexibility in how they put that into practice. [F9] The manual also says a state may limit the waiver to the time the hardship lasts. [F9] Each state’s own criteria weren’t part of our research. [F9]
Examples states are asked to consider
The manual says the law’s legislative history calls for special consideration when the estate is: [F10]
- The only income-producing asset of survivors with limited income, like a family farm or business.
- A homestead of modest value.
- Other compelling circumstances.
It suggests states consider those examples. [F10] Those are examples states are asked to consider, and the manual says states don’t have to adopt them, so they aren’t rights. [F10] And the manual we’re quoting is the 2001 revision; whether a later revision changed it is something we couldn’t confirm. [F9]
The notice and the right to apply
The manual says states must let affected people apply for an undue hardship waiver, and that the procedures must, at a minimum, give advance notice of any proposed recovery. [F11] They must also explain how to apply, the hearing and appeal rights, and the time frames. [F11] The actual time frames weren’t in our sources, so we won’t give any. [F11]
The manual says the notice itself should include: [F12]
- The action the state intends to take.
- The reason.
- The right to a hearing and how to get one.
- How to apply for a hardship waiver.
- The amount to be recovered.
So if a notice arrives, it’s worth reading closely, because it should explain how to ask for a waiver. [F11, F12]
Back to the question
How is this legal? Federal law requires states to seek recovery from the estates of certain people, including people who were 55 or older when they got Medicaid nursing facility or home and community-based services, and related hospital and prescription drug services. [F1, F2] It also makes recovery wait while a surviving spouse is alive or while there’s a child under 21 or blind or disabled [F6], requires hardship waiver procedures [F8], and lets each state decide, within limits, how far the estate reaches. [F13, F14]
Three questions for your family:
- Is a parent getting long-term care through Medicaid?
- Is there a surviving spouse, or a child under 21 or blind or disabled?
- What does your state’s Medicaid agency say about recovery claims and hardship?
For your own situation, talk to an elder law attorney in your state.
Sources
- 42 U.S.C. §1396p (Social Security Act §1917), subsections (a)(1) and (b)(1)–(4), U.S. Code, via Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute
- State Medicaid Manual, Part 3, §3810 “Medicaid Estate Recoveries” (Rev. 75, 2001; manual download, ZIP), Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)