Episode 09
Transfer-on-Death Deeds: Where They Go Wrong
Can a deed that only works at death do the job, and what makes one fail? Here’s what the written law of two states, Missouri and Oregon, says, one state at a time: what the deed is, and six ways it can go wrong.
Key points
- In Missouri and in Oregon, each one state, the deed is made now and the transfer happens at the owner’s death, if the deed is recorded before the death. [F1, F6]
- In Oregon, the deed must name the beneficiary; a designation that identifies beneficiaries only as members of a group is void. [F6]
- In Oregon, once the deed is recorded, tearing it up doesn’t revoke it; revoking takes one of three documents, recorded before the death. [F4, F8]
- In Oregon, the beneficiary takes the property subject to mortgages, liens and certain claims. [F11, F13]
Episode notes
The question that started it
The episode started from a question posted on Reddit, titled “TOD Deed to Trust or just Transfer Direct to Trust.” We quote only the title here. A TOD deed is a transfer-on-death deed. In the two states we checked, it’s a deed that names who gets a property, with the transfer happening at the owner’s death. [F1, F6] Underneath the trust part sits a basic question: can a deed that only works at death do the job, and what makes one fail? We work backwards from six ways it can fail. We won’t answer the poster’s case for them.
What it is
Missouri (one state). A deed that names who gets the property, and expressly says it doesn’t take effect until the owner’s death, transfers that interest at the death, if it’s signed and filed of record with the recorder of deeds where the property is, before the death. [F1] Missouri calls it a beneficiary deed, and it doesn’t have to be paid for or handed to the person it names. [F2]
Oregon (one state). A transfer on death deed works without notice to the beneficiary, without the beneficiary accepting it, and without payment. [F7]
So in both states, the deed is made now, but the transfer happens at the death. [F1, F6]
Failure 1: not recorded in time
Missouri. The deed has to be filed of record before the owner’s death. [F1]
Oregon. It must be recorded before the death, in the deed records of the county clerk for the county where the property is located. [F6]
Where to record it, and what that involves, is something the county recording office can explain.
Failure 2: “to my kids”, with no names
Oregon. The deed must identify the beneficiary by name. [F6] A designation that identifies beneficiaries only as members of a group is void. [F6]
Failure 3: torn up, not revoked
Oregon. A transfer on death deed can be revoked even if it says it can’t be. [F4] But once it’s recorded, tearing it up or crossing it out doesn’t revoke it. [F8] Revoking takes one of three documents, acknowledged by the owner and recorded before the death: [F8]
- a new transfer on death deed that revokes it;
- a document that expressly revokes it; or
- a regular deed that transfers the property during life.
Failure 4: capacity or pressure
Oregon. The capacity needed to make or revoke one of these deeds is the same as the capacity needed to make a will. [F5] A deed procured by fraud, duress or undue influence is void. [F5] A challenge on those grounds has to be started no later than 18 months after the death. [F5]
Failure 5: the person named dies first
Oregon. Unless the deed says otherwise, a beneficiary who doesn’t survive the owner gets nothing; their share lapses. [F10] Surviving has a set meaning there: unless the deed deals with survival itself, a named person is treated as having died first unless it’s shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that they outlived the owner by at least 120 hours. [F15, F20] Those deed-terms exceptions aren’t the only ones in the code. [F20]
A divorce or annulment after the deed is recorded revokes its gifts to the former spouse, as if the former spouse died first, unless the deed shows a different intent. [F16] When several beneficiaries share the property, they take equal shares with no right of survivorship, and a lapsed share goes to the others. [F10] And if the owner co-owned the property in a way that gives the survivor the whole property, what Oregon’s code calls a joint owner, and that other owner outlives them, the property belongs to the surviving joint owner. [F12, F19]
Failure 6: “the house comes free and clear”
Oregon. The beneficiary takes the property subject to mortgages, liens and other interests, including a state’s claim for public or medical assistance, if the owner’s probate assets aren’t enough to pay it. [F11] The owner’s probate case can also go after the property for allowed creditor claims, if the probate assets fall short. [F13] That has to be started no later than 18 months after the death. [F13] While the owner is alive, though, the deed doesn’t affect their right to sell the property or borrow against it, and it gives the beneficiary no interest yet. [F9] For how a state’s Medicaid recovery works, see Episode 06.
Back to the trust question
Missouri. A beneficiary deed can name a trust, whether or not the trust can be revoked. [F3]
Oregon. The code’s definition of who can be named includes a trustee. [F17]
Whether to use a deed like this or move the property into a trust directly, how other states handle it, and anything about taxes: our sources for this episode don’t say, so that’s a question for a lawyer or a tax professional in your state.
Where it can go wrong: a checklist
These questions only sort what to ask about. They don’t decide whether a deed works; the county recording office or a lawyer can.
Oregon (one state)
- Is each beneficiary named, not just described as a group? [F6]
- Was any change made by a recorded document, not by tearing up the deed? [F8]
- Are there concerns about the owner’s capacity, or about pressure? [F5]
- What does the deed say if a beneficiary dies first, or after a divorce? [F10, F15, F16, F20]
- Are there mortgages, liens or claims that come with the property? [F11, F13]
Which state’s rules are we describing?
What to ask
Oregon’s own form for these deeds carries this notice: “You should carefully read all information on this form. You may want to consult a lawyer before using this form. This form must be recorded before your death or it will not be effective.” [F14] We quote the notice only; we don’t host the form.
The county recording office, or a lawyer in your state, can tell you whether a deed like this is available where the property is, and how it gets recorded.
Back to the question
Can a deed that only works at death do the job, and what makes one fail? In Missouri and in Oregon, each one state, it can transfer a property at the death, if it meets that state’s requirements, including being recorded before the death. [F1, F6] In Oregon’s rules, it goes wrong with no names, a deed torn up instead of revoked, doubts about capacity or pressure, a beneficiary who dies first, or debts and claims that still come with the house. [F5, F6, F8, F10, F11]
Sources
- Mo. Rev. Stat. §461.025, Missouri Revisor of Statutes
- Or. Rev. Stat. chapter 93 (ORS 93.948 to 93.985), Oregon State Legislature
- Or. Rev. Stat. chapter 112 (ORS 112.570 to 112.590), Oregon State Legislature